30 days of gratitude days 10 and 11: the revs. margaret bonner and geraldine granger

evensongBefore I ever heard a woman preach, when I knew it was theoretically possible, but did not know where or how to find it, I discovered two fictional women ministers: The Rev. Margaret Bonner, an episcopal priest in Gail Godwin’s Evensong and Geraldine Granger, an anglican priest in the BBC’s The Vicar of Dibley. Neither of these women was perfect, but each was sincere and real. And they made it seem so possible, as if such women actually existed (which, it turns out, they did). There is a first book (Father Melancholy’s Daughter) about Margaret that explains much of what is in the background of the second book, but I read the second book first and it holds a special place in my heart.200px-Vicar_of_Dibley_DVD (I will admit I have read other Gail Godwin books, and haven’t been able to get enthused, even the ones about people in academia. Go figure.) The Vicar of Dibley is just great good fun with a bit of heart and soul thrown in.

How my mind works:
I haven’t read Evensong in awhile, but “Our God Our Help in Ages Past” (in the Presbyterian Hymnal it is “Our God Our Help”, and not “O God Our Help”) was our closing hymn yesterday, and I looked up the lyrics as I wrote the prayers of the people, trying to get a feel for why it was the closing hymn for worship on Veteran’s Day weekend. As I came across the line “a thousand ages in thy sight are like an evening gone” something was triggered in my head: someone used that in a book. I thought of Evensong immediately, and discarded it, thinking I was getting the title mixed up with the line, but I couldn’t think of another author or book and it kept niggling at me until I pulled out the book, remembered the video Ben sent Margaret, and found it. So. It’s that kind of book.

This entry was posted in About Me, Books, Gratitude, TV. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to 30 days of gratitude days 10 and 11: the revs. margaret bonner and geraldine granger

  1. Elizabeth Nordquist says:

    Gail Godwin’s books on Margaret Bonner are among my all-time favorite; like you, I am not as wild about the others. Father Melancholy’s Daughter was really transformative for me , since I had a very depressed father, one who did not believe I should be ordained. I just saw The Vicar of Dibley in these past few months, and I am going to be loaned the extra special in which she gets married shortly. Isn’t the gift of literature in book and film a gracious and beautiful one?!

    • bookgirl says:

      A gracious and beautiful gift, indeed.

      Hah! I almost asked in my post what you thought of Godwin. I should read Father Melancholy’s Daughter again. (So much to read…)

      I bought the boxed set of Vicar of Dibley before the extra specials came out. I have those two discs on loan from our mutual friend. If you happen to be waiting for those particular copies, I think I need to finish up.

      (On a side note, I am missing my friend Inspector Gamache. I started reading the Duncan Kincaid/Jemma James books by Deborah Crombie, and I so want them to be Gamache and Lacoste, and they just aren’t.)

      • Elizabeth Nordquist says:

        No they are not. But they are who they are, and do pass the time quite pleasantly!

        I am getting my Vicar loans from a San Fernando Valley source, so no hurry on my account!

  2. Deanna long says:

    So much to learn!

Thoughts, Questions, Comments?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s